Colonoscopy and Screening Errors

A colonoscopy is the most accurate way to examine the colon. It is also performed by humans, under time pressure, and it can be done inadequately.

The colonoscopy is the most accurate tool for examining the entire colon, and has the advantage of allowing the physician to remove and biopsy polyps during the same procedure. When it is performed properly and its results are acted upon, it prevents colon cancer outright by removing polyps before they turn malignant.

When it is not, a patient can be told they are clear when they are not. Cancers diagnosed after a colonoscopy that was reported as normal — sometimes called interval cancers — are a recognized phenomenon and, in some cases, a recognized failure of care.

Common colonoscopy and screening failures

Inadequate bowel preparation

A colon that is not adequately cleared cannot be adequately examined. Residual stool obscures the lining of the colon and hides polyps and small tumors. Where a procedure is performed despite clearly inadequate preparation — or where the prep instructions were never properly given — lesions can be missed. A reasonable practice is either to reschedule or to document and account for the limitation.

An incomplete examination

Reaching the cecum — the beginning of the colon — is a basic quality marker for colonoscopy. When the scope does not reach it, part of the colon has not been examined. If the patient is not told, and no further evaluation is arranged, a cancer in the unexamined segment can grow undetected.

Missed polyps and lesions

Polyps can be missed because of a rushed withdrawal, poor distension of the colon, inadequate preparation, or simple inattention. Withdrawal time is a recognized quality indicator for this reason. A polyp that is seen but not removed — or not biopsied — is a separate and clearer failure.

Failure to recommend follow-up after a polyp is found

Finding a polyp creates an obligation: it must be removed or biopsied, pathology must be reviewed, and a surveillance interval must be recommended. A patient with a history of polyps needs earlier and more frequent follow-up than an average-risk patient. When that recommendation is never made, recurrence can go undetected.

Results never communicated or never acted on

This is among the most recurring failures in delayed diagnosis cases. A pathology report showing cancer or a high-grade dysplastic polyp is filed in a chart and never reaches the patient. A positive fecal occult blood test is never followed by a colonoscopy. A recommended work-up is never scheduled.

Sigmoidoscopy mistaken for complete evaluation

A sigmoidoscopy examines only the left side of the colon. If a polyp is found, a full colonoscopy is normally recommended so the entire colon can be inspected. Where that recommendation is not made — or is made and not followed up — cancer in the right colon can develop undetected.

Sedation and monitoring errors

Colonoscopy with sedation carries its own risks, including cardiorespiratory complications. These are procedural negligence questions rather than diagnostic ones, but they are part of the same family of claims.

Is a missed cancer automatically malpractice?

No. Some lesions are genuinely difficult or impossible to see, and a cancer can develop in the interval between properly scheduled examinations. The question is not whether a cancer was missed, but why:

  • Was the bowel preparation adequate?
  • Was the examination complete and documented as such?
  • Were polyps found and removed, and was pathology reviewed?
  • Was an appropriate surveillance interval recommended, and communicated?
  • Were abnormal results acted on within a reasonable time?

Where the answer to any of these is no, and a cancer went undetected as a result, there may be a claim. See failure to diagnose and delayed diagnosis for how the elements of such a claim are established.

Records decide these cases

The colonoscopy report, the pathology report, the preparation instructions, procedure notes and the follow-up correspondence are the documents that determine whether an error occurred. If you believe a colonoscopy missed your cancer, those records should be obtained and reviewed promptly. Request a free case review.

Has your colon cancer diagnosis been delayed?

Every state limits how long you have to file. A free, confidential review costs you nothing and tells you where you stand.