Failure to Diagnose and Delayed Diagnosis of Colon Cancer

A missed diagnosis is rarely a single dramatic mistake. It is usually a series of small omissions, each defensible on its own, that together cost a patient years.

What “failure to diagnose” means

Failure to diagnose colon cancer, and delayed diagnosis of colon cancer, describe the same core harm: a patient had the disease, the medical system had opportunities to find it, and it was not found until later. In practice the delay comes from one or more of the following.

1. Screening that was never offered

Guidelines recommend screening for average-risk adults beginning at age 45, and earlier where there is a family history or other risk factors. When a primary care physician sees a patient year after year and never orders or discusses screening, the opportunity to find a precancerous polyp is lost repeatedly.

2. Symptoms that were not investigated

Rectal bleeding attributed to hemorrhoids. Iron deficiency anemia treated with supplements and no search for the source. A change in bowel habits treated with dietary advice. Unexplained weight loss attributed to stress. Each of these is a missed opportunity, and the pattern is common. See the warning signs that should trigger testing.

3. Tests that were ordered but not followed up

A fecal occult blood test returns positive and no colonoscopy is scheduled. A polyp is found on sigmoidoscopy and the recommended colonoscopy never happens. A biopsy is taken and the pathology report is never acted on. These failures usually involve a breakdown in communication between physician, patient and sometimes a specialist — and can be among the strongest cases, because the standard of care was clearly identified and clearly not met.

4. Results that were misread

Biopsy results misinterpreted, a lesion seen on imaging but not recognized, a pathology report signed off without review. Diagnostic error is a recognized and serious form of medical negligence.

5. A colonoscopy that missed the cancer

Colonoscopy is not infallible. A cancer can be missed during an adequate examination, and it can also be missed because the examination was inadequate — poor bowel preparation, an incomplete procedure, or an insufficiently careful withdrawal. See colonoscopy and screening errors.

The harm a delay causes

Colon cancer generally grows slowly over years, which is what makes a delay in diagnosis so consequential. The delay does not merely postpone treatment — it changes what treatment is possible:

  • The cancer advances from a stage curable by polypectomy or limited resection to a stage requiring surgery plus adjuvant chemotherapy
  • The cancer advances from a potentially curable stage to Stage IV, where treatment becomes palliative
  • An enlarging tumor obstructs the bowel, converting a planned operation into emergency surgery — and often a colostomy that might otherwise have been avoided
  • The patient loses the chance of a better outcome — sometimes described as loss of chance — even where a cure was not guaranteed
  • The patient endures additional suffering, additional procedures and additional cost

Survival rates by stage show what those stage differences mean in numbers.

The elements of a delayed diagnosis claim

To pursue a claim, four things generally have to be established:

  1. Duty

    A health care provider owed the patient a duty of care — which is almost always satisfied when a physician undertakes treatment.

  2. Breach

    The provider departed from accepted standards of medical care. This is usually established with the help of physician experts who review the records and testify about what a reasonably careful physician would have done.

  3. Causation

    The departure caused the delay, and the delay caused harm. This is usually the most heavily contested element and the most dependent on the medical chronology.

  4. Damages

    The patient suffered measurable harm: a worse prognosis, lost treatment options, additional medical expenses, lost earnings, pain and suffering, or wrongful death.

Not every delay is malpractice

Some cancers progress quickly despite appropriate care, and some delays are attributable to the patient rather than the physician. A claim exists only where the care fell below accepted standards and that failure caused harm. Determining this requires a medical and legal review — which we provide at no charge. Request a free case review.

What records matter most

In evaluating a delayed diagnosis case, the chronology drives everything: when symptoms were first reported, what tests were ordered, when results were returned, who saw them, what was done in response, and when the diagnosis was finally made. Gaps in that chronology are often where the case lives.

Has your colon cancer diagnosis been delayed?

Every state limits how long you have to file. A free, confidential review costs you nothing and tells you where you stand.