Stage 1: The initial consultation and case review
A case typically begins when a patient or family member suspects that a bad outcome was the result of negligence. Not every bad result is malpractice — but if something about the care felt wrong, the appropriate step is to consult a qualified attorney.
The attorney reviews the available facts to determine whether the injury and the provider's conduct could rise to the level of a claim. This can take time, because it may require review of medical records and consultation with physicians and other health care professionals to assess whether the provider's actions fell below accepted medical standards. The case has to be evaluated from both a legal and a medical perspective.
Stage 2: Deadline analysis — before anything else
Every malpractice claim is governed by a filing deadline. Determining it comes first, because it dictates how much time exists to investigate. See statute of limitations and filing deadlines.
Stage 3: Obtaining and reviewing the medical records
The medical chronology in a colon cancer case usually spans several providers: primary care, gastroenterology, pathology, radiology, oncology and surgery. Records must be requested, organized and read. This is where the case is largely won or lost: the question is who knew what, when, and what they did about it.
Stage 4: Expert review
Medical malpractice cases generally require physician experts to establish the standard of care and to opine on whether it was breached and whether that breach caused harm. In many jurisdictions, an expert opinion or affidavit is a prerequisite to filing or to proceeding past an early screening stage.
Massachusetts note
Massachusetts requires a medical malpractice tribunal in most cases before the claim can proceed to trial, and a separate statutory notice of intent to sue must generally be served on the provider before filing. Other states impose their own screening, notice or certificate requirements. These are general descriptions, not legal advice, and the specifics depend on your facts and jurisdiction.
Stage 5: Filing and the litigation process
If the facts support a claim, it may be appropriate to file in court and commence the lawsuit. This is often necessary because malpractice claims rarely settle unless filed — and even then, many of the claims that are filed proceed to trial.
Once filed, both sides develop the merits of their case. Typical steps include:
- Written discovery — the exchange of documents and answers to interrogatories
- Depositions — sworn testimony from the parties, treating physicians and experts
- Medical examinations — you may be required to undergo further physical examinations and testing at the defendant's request
- Scheduling order and trial date — assigned by the court once these steps are complete
All cases should be prepared as though they will need to go to trial. Then, if the case does not settle, you and your attorney will be in the best position possible to try it.
Stage 6: Resolution
Cases resolve by settlement before trial, settlement during trial, verdict at trial, or — occasionally — appeal. There is no way to predict which. Some cases settle before a lawsuit is even filed, but many do not, and a case that does not settle can take several years to litigate to trial. An appeal can extend that further.
What it costs
Many attorneys who handle medical malpractice cases work on a contingency fee basis. The attorney does not charge an hourly rate; instead the attorney is paid a percentage of any recovery from a settlement, award or judgment, and is paid only if a recovery is obtained for the client. Many attorneys also wait until the resolution of the case to recover expenses such as expert fees and deposition costs.
Financial concerns should not prevent someone who suspects malpractice from immediately contacting a qualified attorney. Request a free consultation.
Damages and limits
Depending on the state, recoverable damages may include medical expenses, lost earnings and earning capacity, pain and suffering, and — in fatal cases — wrongful death damages. Some states cap certain categories of damages. Comparative fault rules may reduce a recovery if the patient is found partly responsible. The outcome of any case depends on its specific facts; no result is guaranteed.